As expected the immigration debate has dominated the national political scene, most of it led by Donald Trump. Which is appropriate because Donald Trump represents the “white privilege” minority. There are two things that drive the immigration debate. These are changes in the cultural makeup of the United States and economics. Some of you are likely arguing that I forgot to include border security in the mix. As I am going to show you, border security is a red herring to what really drives the fear of immigration, the fear of cultural diversity and economics. The real underlining fear about immigration is cultural diversity followed by self-serving economic fears. The real truth is that these fears are being magnified by a minority fearful that they are losing “white privilege” in the United States.
Before I explain the white privilege problem, let me discuss the issue of economics and immigration. It is a fact that immigrants, especially Mexican immigrants keep wages down. For Mexican’s the great driver for immigrating to the United States is economic. We must accept that Mexican immigrants help keep wages low because they are willing to work for less. However, is that a bad thing?
Low wages are not a bad thing because the fact is that the majority of US citizens benefit from low wages. The problem is not the low wages but the fact that US citizens want low prices on consumer goods while at the same time they want high wages for their menial jobs. (High-tech and specialized jobs still command high wages in the US.) In essence, US citizens want their cake and to eat as well.
We do not need to look further than what I call the “Walmart effect.” US consumers, especially those that complain about immigrants taking jobs away, shop for their consumer goods based on the lowest price point possible. The fact is that the vast majority of the US consumer goods are Chinese. Their quality is low as their prices as well. Even higher-end goods, like iPhones come from Asia because the pressure to keep low prices has created a worldwide supply chain of components and labor based on the lowest price point possible. This keeps the iPhones as cheap as possible thus increasing the US consumer market. Those that complain about low wages ignore the fact that they benefit from them when they purchase their consumables.
The cultural diversity issue is the real driving force behind the Donald Trump immigration rhetoric. It is based on the fear of losing the US “white privilege” identity that Trump’s supporters have magnified through him. Make no mistake, it is a minority whose voices have been magnified by Donald Trump’s celebrity status.
“White privilege” is the fear of losing the Anglo-centric cultural identity of the United States. It is the fear that the English language is being replaced by other languages, especially Spanish. It is also the fear that the Anglo-centric culture is diversifying through cultural diversity. What “white privilege” adherents forget is that the United States has always been culturally diverse. What has changed is the rise of political assertions by the dormant majority, especially the Hispanics that make up the nation.
The Southwest United States, which is a significant component of the country in terms of population and area, has always been dominated by Spanish language and the Hispanic/Latino culture. When Mexico lost the US-Mexico War the inhabitants of the lost territories remained Hispanic and Spanish dominant. They did not assimilate into the Anglo-centric culture. What changed over time is that the Hispanic population emerged from a political stupor, slowly at first and growing as the population grew and self-determination began to assert itself.
This is the underlining fear of immigration reform and it is best exemplified by Donald Trump.
Look closely at Trump’s immigration rhetoric and his personal actions on immigration. The fact is that Donald Trump targets the southern border when he discussed immigration, ignoring the Anglo-centric northern border. Trump has also demonstrated that he has no problem with immigration as long as it comes from the right places. For example, he is married to an immigrant. As a matter of fact, Donald Trump himself came from immigrants, like many US citizens. The immigrants in Trump’s life all adhere to the Anglo-centric image.
But the fact remains that the “white privilege” is a minority when it comes to the view of US citizens, although Donald Trump’s celebrity creates the illusion that it is a majority of US citizens. To understand this let’s look at a recent report on the views of US citizens about immigrants and immigration reform.
Last week, the Public Religion Research Institute published “How Americans View Immigrants, and What They Want from Immigration Reform, Findings from the 2015 American Values Atlas.” The Public Religion Research Institute is a US non-profit and nonpartisan research institution focused on religion and US values studies. Clergy, scholars and journalists routinely use their reports as source material for a better understanding of US general public opinion.
According to the PRRI, the “American Values Atlas (AVA) is a landmark project designed to provide an unprecedented portrait of American attitudes on important issues.” The 2015 AVA is based “on data from over 42,000 bilingual telephone interviews conducted among a random sample of Americans between May 2015 and early January 2016.” [emphasis mine]
Clearly, the sampling is good indicator of US resident attitudes about immigration. According to the report, only 34% of US residents feel that immigrants are a “threat to American customs and values.” Fifty-percent of those surveyed agree that “newcomers from other countries strengthen American society.” When you break down the results by age group it becomes abundantly clear that “white privilege” is an important factor to the immigration debate. Only 36% of those 65 and older “believe that newcomers strengthen American society.” Forty-four percent of this age group believe that immigrants “are a threat” to the US. However, 68% of those between 18 and 29 believe that immigrants “strengthen” the US. As you can see, older US citizens are fearful of cultural diversity in the US.
Unfortunately for immigrants, it is the older citizens that are more likely to vote and thus their minority vote is amplified through the elections. That is changing though, and cultural minorities are beginning to exercise their rights to vote, thus the fear of the “white privilege” minority.
Look closely at the attitudes of the Anglo-centric respondents who were surveyed and you being to understand the “white privilege” phenomena. “Fewer than half of Mormons (45%), white Catholics (44%), and white mainline Protestants (41%) believe immigrants strengthen the country,” according to the report.
Even then, the gap between white religious groups and others in regards to their perceptions of immigrants is narrowing each year. Thus the fear of losing the “white privilege” is the underlining theme behind the Donald Trump immigration politics. Even among the Republicans, the gap is narrowing. Except for the “Conservative Republicans” who polled at 58%, the other two, the “Moderate” and “Liberal” Republicans are a minority who fear that immigrants erode US culture, values and customs.
The most surprising result of the survey is the attitudes about a pathway to citizenship of undocumented immigrants.
Of those surveyed, 62% agree that “immigrants who are currently living here illegally should be allowed a way to become citizens provided they meet certain requirements.” Only 19%, believe that “illegal immigrants should be identified and deported.”
Yes, you read that correctly, a vast majority of the respondents agree that undocumented immigrants should be provided a pathway to legalizing their stay in the US. Some of you probably do not believe that because Donald Trump has magnified the beliefs of a clear minority through the news media.
I realize that some of you will argue that the survey is skewed or that it did not survey the attitudes of the electorate. The fact remains that unless a more thorough survey is produced, the PRRI survey is the most accurate glimpse of the real attitudes of US citizens in the immigration debate. I would be willing to wager that a survey of the general US electorate would produce the same results.
Donald Trump’s voice may be loud and he magnifies a minority view point through the news media but the fact remains that the majority of US residents view immigrants and cultural diversity in a favorable light. Donald Trump represents that “white privilege” that fears losing its cultural identity in the ever-evolving US cultural identity.
I highly encourage you to read the report, it is very revealing about US attitudes towards immigration. You can download it by clicking here.
Oh come, when will you stop using the racial card. The nation has been diverse for decades. The vast majority of the ethic groups took their licks and assimilated, now the success is based on personal achievement and their efforts. Some will do better than others but then everyone can’t come in first place .
Why does Mexico have draconian immigration laws and strict enforcement, why does it have wall on the Southern boundary ? Is it fear of losing its Hispanic culture and identity? All the those central and South Americans are going to over run Mexico and force to adopt a foreign culture, a different dialect, a different accent.
Europe is perfect example of what happens when countries are over run and the immigrants refuse to assimilate and want to force their customs on the new countries. It’s pure chaos.
Trump is no more a racist then the average person that use racial epithets at home or among friends. Btw, don’t try to say that my comments are an indication of an endorsement of anyone. One could turn the tables and say YOU(Martin) are a racist. The endless attacks on the American way of life, which IS diverse ! How would you explain successful people of all colors and ethic groups ? How would you explain the diversity in politics ? What you want is complete domination of the U.S. and make it a country without identity or common goals.
Why haven’t you assimilated ? If you have a distaste for the U.S. , why stay here ? Is it because deep inside you know this is the best country in world.
Low wages, no education, no medical care, no equality, only two groups-one realty and the other extremely poor. That’s Mexico ! That IS a true example of a privileged group and no diversity. Yet, there is no mention of those conditions or the southern Mexican border or Mexico’s war on the Indigenous people, the ongoing war to dominate the Indians into even worse conditions, to destroy their heritage. They were there first. Isnt that the argument that is used by Mexico? So why should they assimilate ?
Well we want some of that White privilege others and keep you talking about since we never got any or our parents or siblings much less our children . Sorry Martin the claims of white privilege is mostly “BULL SHIT”. So if you want to use such non-sense how about Hispanic privilege in El Paso and El Paso county.
Once again we ask the question seems some like you Martin can’t answer if white America is so racist, repressive, oppressive where is the mass exodus of minority out of the U.S.? What we see is minorities trying to get into the U.S even risking their lives to do so to get into such a racist, repressive, oppressive nation.
The “right” immigrants love our country, obey our laws and assimilate our values. The wrong immigrants have situational ethics, pick and choose what laws they obey, don’t want to assimilate, practice discrimination in employment of anyone not like them (often through unnecessary language fluency requirements) and in general want the privileges of citizenship with none of the responsibilities or loyalty that should come with that. If I wrote a blog in Mexico criticizing Mexican nationalism, I’d be kicked out of the country. Trump exists because folks are starting to realize that your talking points aren’t making us a stronger country.
When I travel and people ask me what El Paso is like, I tell them it is the American face of Mexico; it is a Mexican city in the USA. They draw their own conclusions about the value of more Mexican immigration.
As for the northern border, what is the problem? No one in Canada wants to immigrate here. I spent the summer in BC and seriously considered becoming a resident there. They are healthier, happier, and wealthier than us.
Martin, blog on this…
Hey Martin, blog on this…
Well stated Martin. The truth always hurt when one has been misinformed. I am not surprised by your audience’s remarks, it reflects the party line division. The true Majority is now the true Minority; the Native American. The privileged white population now has to assimilate instead of the other way around. That is the uproar we are now hearing mostly from Trump supporters. Again, well stated!
The privileged white population now has to assimilate instead of the other way around.
Pedro, yes, we’re looking forward to more violence, corruption, poverty and never having to show up for anything on time. Assimilation to Mexican culture is going to make us all rich and slim.
I can’t speak for others, my comments have nothing to do with politics, just facts.
As usual, people try to split facts with politics.
Pedro, why is the Mexican southern wall ignored, why isn’t the Mexican immigration laws discussed, why aren’t crimes against migrants from central and South America discussed, why aren’t the crimes against the Mexican Indians discussed? Why isn’t the Mexican government neglect of its citizens discussed? Why isn’t the actual two classes system in Mexico discussed.
Are they inconvient facts. The standard being only the U.S. is accountable and Mexico gets a pass ? Isn’t that hyprocisy ?
If we really want to see this issue without political lenses, then let’s not forget the Mexican “white” elite… “Certainly, Mexican immigration to the U.S. helps Mexico`s white elite to stay in power. Jorge Castañeda, now Fox`s Foreign Minister, stated as much in his famed Atlantic Monthly article of July 1995. The white Mexican elite is determined to keep as many of their poorer, darker-skinned countrymen heading north. The emigration “safety valve” was Zedillo`s policy, and now it`s Fox`s policy—the new president is just more aggressive about it.”
Lengthy but worth the read: http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/97feb/mexico/castaned.htm
I did not get from the article that it was so much a racial policy as it was a safety valve to protect overall Mexican social stability by letting the poorest find an outlet in the USA. Trump’s promise to make Mexico build the wall by threatening to cut off the vital billions of dollar transfers from migrants – legal and illegal – in the USA could have teeth. But by the author’s reckoning could tip Mexico into chaos.
Either way we all lose. It would just be so nice if the crack between the North and Central America plates that is the Rio Grande Valley would give way and let a 100 miles of water flow between us. El Paso would suddenly become beach front property, too, solving our tax base problem in one stroke.
Martin, Martin, Martin, Pedro
Yep for people like Martin and Pedro it’s always whitey’s failed and they never want to even address or talk about Mexico’s draconian immigration laws and behavior on this issues, If the U.S. applied the same laws as Mexico and treated illegal immigrants as bad Martin,Pedro and others would be screaming their lungs out.
My question is so who is hold you back in El Paso can’t blame it on Whitey?
Also Padro maybe would help to understand of population demographics in America and maybe it’s more blending of the races as opposed to one race taking over from another.
Way to go Martin. The shorts of the local bigots are all in a bunch. They say the U.S. is exceptional, yet they want us to copy the standards of Mexico. I’m sure they all want to vote for Trump even though they won’t admit it, especially Barbara.
Anita, can you not or comprehend? Nobody said we wanted to copy Mexico. The truth is YOU want the U.S. to copy Mexico ! YOU are the bigot with all the anti-US comments you post.
Based on your comments you are either a Hillary the Liar supporter or the socialist sanders supporter. The socialist that would sink 18 billion dollars for freebies. Who knows you probably want to hold Mexican elections here.
I recommend you gargle with all the stench you spew.
You not only have bad breath but are also a liar. I have posted nothing that is anti-US. Just anti-bigots like you. I will vote for the first woman president Hillary Rodham Clinton.
anita, then you are an idiot if you would vote for that lying criminal.
Oh really, next president is based on gender? What’s your next vote ? A cross eyed, toothless pigmy ? That would be a first.
Obviously you are another of el Paso’s finest uninformed voter
Comments are closed.