Last week, Otto Warmbier was transferred from North Korea back to his country, the United States. Warmbier arrived back in the U.S. in a coma he suffered from unknown reasons. In 2016, Warmbier was jailed by North Korea for stealing a propaganda poster from the hotel he was staying at. He was arrested at the airport before his flight out of North Korea. Sentenced to 15 years, Warmbier was released in a comatose state last week.
There is no doubt that North Korea is a rogue state. There is also no doubt that North Korean officials do not follow the standards of fairness and basic humanity that most of us believe are essential rights for all human beings. And therein lies the problem. Because Warmbier is a U.S. citizen, the news media from many parts of the world, and many government officials have taken up his case to illustrate the horrors of North Korea.
The issue is that Otto Warmbier made a conscious decision to travel to an authoritarian country whose standards of fairness and governance are not acceptable to most of us. Warmbier went for a visit and, unfortunately, returned in a comatose state after likely being severely beaten. But Otto Warmbier wasn’t arrested just because some North Korean official wanted to make a name for themselves. Warmbier was arrested for tearing off a poster from the wall of the hotel he was staying at. Not only did Warmbier travel to a country the United States specifically tells its citizens not to travel to, but he also committed a crime, however small, while there.
Otto Warmbier does not deserve what he suffered, but neither should the decisions he made that led him down his path be ignored. While most are decrying what happened to him, many aren’t asking the simple question of what about the hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of North Koreans who suffer each day. Very few of them, if any, made the decision to be born in North Korea and to suffer under that regime.
Therefore, the question that begs to be asked, at what point are individuals expected to be responsible for their own decisions. If you are outraged by what happened to Warmbier, you should be more outraged by what happens to hundreds of thousands of North Koreans day in and day out. Warmbier had the luxury of making the decision that put him in his predicament. How many North Koreans have that luxury? It may not be proper to put it in these terms, but it is the reality that it must be discussed under.
I agree that traveling to North Korea was a bad decision, but we don’t know that he did tear a propaganda poster off the wall. It could simply have been that North Korea decided to detain another US citizen or even that a hotel worker decided to make his life a living hell by reporting that a guest had torn a poster off a wall. I’ve done the Pamunjon tour. There is a briefing for visitors that explains that looking a North Korea guard in the eye, smiling or waving will result in North Korea claiming you are attempting to convince their people to defect. In short, they lie all the time about what Americans do.
NK is a concentration camp state. The issue that I’m sure everyone is watching is whether their leader is sane. A psychonaut with nukes is a threat to the whole world and cannot be allowed to continue. Unlike Saddam Hussein whose sociopathic tendencies were a threat to Iraq and not to us.
While I agree there are plans to visit NK, haven’t we all made pretty stupid mistakes?
I ask on a larger scale, at what point does the Mexican government become responsible for the people ? A country that is rich in resources. Yet is very poor except for the elite. If the government helped the people, perhaps they wouldn’t flee or work for the cartels.
“Therefore, the question that begs to be asked, at what point are individuals expected to be responsible for their own decisions.” Martin, you say this about a young man who makes a stupid mistake, yet when it comes to millions of illegal aliens you put your head in the sand. I agree we should be responsible for our own decisions. When someone goes to or stays in any country illegally, why are they surprised and why do they play the victim card when they are deported?
Uh, you’re totally off base. NK purposely lures US citizens via this tour business and then look for reasons to kidnap them. It was inexcusable how they treated this guy(almost a kid at 22) over a stupid poster, and yes who knows if that is true. He was an American citizen, a good person and that’s all I care about. Couldn’t care less about the poor people in NK, they’ve had this family ruling for years and should’ve risen up and overthrown them. Their choice to stay in that cesspool, no compassion for them and I have none for any people who support violent, backwards nations , politics and religions.
Comments are closed.