Most of the vocal narrative about undocumented immigrants is surrounded by many falsehoods that is perpetuated to support the notion that undocumented immigrants are criminals. The use of the word “illegal” and the notion that to be in the United States as an undocumented immigrant is a crime are designed to demonize undocumented immigrants so that it becomes more palatable to stigmatize then when arguing for the wall or for mass deportations. Stigmatizing immigrants conveniently ignores the facts so that the narrative can end by creating the illusion that undocumented immigrants are bad for the country. The problem is that the facts show otherwise.

To be in the country as an undocumented immigrant is not a crime.

Black’s Law Dictionary defines crime as “an act committed or omitted, in violation of a public law.” It adds that a crime is “distinguished from a civil injury.” Those pushing the narrative, to demonize undocumented immigrants, rely on the argument that to be in the country as an undocumented immigrant is “illegal” and thus by that definition the immigrant is a criminal. The problem is that the law does not make it a crime to be in the country in an “out of status” condition.

First, let us define how someone can be undocumented in the United States. There are two ways to enter the United States. The first is via a federally recognized port of entry where the individual, entering the country, is inspected by an agent of Homeland Security. The agent, pursuant to the laws, either admits the immigrant under a specific category into the country or denies them entry. Each category of admittance has its own restrictions.

The second way to enter the country is through an uncontrolled border point. This type of entry is defined as an illegal entry. The act of illegal entry is generally a misdemeanor. However, it can be a felony, if the immigrant has previously been removed, i.e. deported from the country. Generally, a deportee is issued a warning informing them that any reentry will be prosecuted as a felony.

An immigrant who crosses the border and is properly inspected by an immigration agent does not commit a crime by overstaying their visa allowing them entry into the country. Most undocumented immigrants enter the country through a legal point of entry and simply overstay their authorization visa.

Even the anti-immigration Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) group acknowledges that 30% to 40% of undocumented immigrants simply overstayed their visas.

This translates into the fact that 30-40% of undocumented immigrants are not criminals simply by being in the country in an undocumented status. Overstaying an immigrant visa is like a ticket issued to a red-light runner. Both are civil offenses carrying with them civil penalties. Red-light runners pay a fine and visa over stayers are subject to be removed from the country.

In 2005, the House of Representatives tried to criminalize being in the country by overstaying the visa provisions of the immigrant as a criminal act. HR 4437, also known as the Sensenbrenner Bill, passed the House but failed at the Senate.

To this day, it is not a crime to be in the country as an undocumented immigrant if the immigrant was lawfully admitted through a point of entry. That is at least 30% of the undocumented immigrant population.

Interestingly and ignored by those who pursue the narrative of criminalizing undocumented immigrants is that the civil nature of the immigration laws of the country is the single most important reason that immigrants can be expeditiously removed from the country by the border patrol.

This is because the law treats being present in the country as an undocumented immigrant, for those that entered legally, as a civil offense thus eliminating the constitutional protections of court hearings and legal representation. Because the immigrant isn’t charged with a crime, but is instead charged with a civil violation, i.e. being present in the country without documents, then the protections afforded criminal prosecutions are nonexistent. Furthermore, the federal government defines the removal of an immigrant from the country as a civil removal proceeding.

Civil removal proceedings far outnumber criminal prosecutions as the preferred process for removing undocumented immigrants.

If we are to have a meaningful discussion about immigration it is important to understand that a great majority of the undocumented in the country are not criminals.

Martin Paredes

Martín Paredes is a Mexican immigrant who built his business on the U.S.-Mexican border. As an immigrant, Martín brings the perspective of someone who sees México as a native through the experience...

2 replies on “Undocumented Immigrants Are Not All Criminals”

  1. Agree that not all are criminals but to be charged with a misademor makes it a crime. It is recorded in police/court files and adjudicated.

    Most people entering thru the southern border don’t have visas or a passport.

    Is it not a crime to be in other countries without permission, especially in Mexico?

    Ever hear “to steal a penny is the same as stealing a hundred dollars? Let’s stop splitting hairs and parsing. I get your point but you’re wrong.

    So when can we expect Mexico and Central American countries to accept responsibility for their citizens and improve conditions so people won’t feel a need to leave ? I can tell you with certainly that when Mexico changes its ways, the immigration issue will be resolved.

  2. So “undocumented” means you lost your papers? MP sneak into Mexico with no papers and try to work to see what happens.
    PS: They will call you illegal!

Comments are closed.